Monday, February 5, 2007

Isabella: From Auschwitz to Freedom by Isabella Leitner

This is a beautifully written account of the author’s experiences in Auschwitz and other German concentration camps towards the end of World War II. Her mother and youngest sister were killed when they arrived (at a time when the Nazis were burning 24,000 people a day at Auschwitz), but she and two sisters and a brother managed to survive. Surprisingly, it’s hopeful and not depressing. My only beef with her is that she portrays Germans as inhuman or a different species, which seems a dangerous attitude—if we imagine that the Nazis killed the Jews because they’re somehow fundamentally different from the rest of humanity, instead of asking what choices they made to get to that point, then we’ve learned nothing. There have been many, many groups of people who have tortured and murdered other groups, for whatever reason. Most notably, her saviors, the Russians, killed hundreds of thousands more people than the Nazis did. Certainly they had more time for the killing, but there are several specific and short incidents in history when the Russians matched or exceeded the Nazis’ numbers. The question is, what makes people think they can deprive others of life? What leads to that, and are we sure we’re not on a similar path? Would I have risked my own life to save others if I had lived in Germany during World War II? What if my “job” were processing Jews on their way to death camps? I hope I would have been more like the ten Booms in Holland or like Helmut Hübener in Germany, but I don’t know.

Having said that, though, I have no idea how I would react if I were ever in the same situation that Isabella found herself in when she was so young (about 20 years old). I can’t imagine the horror. So I don’t wish to criticize her. I think every first-person account of the Holocaust is valuable and necessary, and I’m grateful there are those brave enough to write about their experiences.

3 comments:

  1. Haven't read this so can't really comment, but I think it's amazing that people can write anything about the Holocaust and end up making it hopeful. I'm glad. I also appreciate your view on Germans being human. It IS a valuable thing to be able to see that anyone could end up being evil if they make the choices that lead them to that end. This doesn't excuse their actions, but just opens us up to learn from them... ...or something like that.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Another great account of life in a concentration camp is The Hiding Place by Corrie ten Boom. She and her sister and other family members hid Jews in their house in Holland. The sisters were in their 50s or 60s and ended up in concentration camps eventually. Theirs is an amazing story because of their very strong faith and desire to teach about Christ. They smuggled a Bible into their camp and taught women every day. It's really an uplifting story.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I recently read a novel by Ursula Hegi called Stones from the River. It's about a dwarf who lived in Germany during World War II. she and her father helped some of their Jewish friends (and other Jews passing through) by hiding them in their basement. it's interesting to read from the perspective of a German. i guess they weren't all nazis... ...really, she's a brave and inspiring character. overall, (although some parts are disturbing), i really enjoyed the book.

    ReplyDelete